Persil Vs Tide The Detergent Battle Rages On

Persil Vs. Tide Which Detergent Cleans Better?

Liquid detergent, pods or pouches, no matter which type you use, there are 2 brand leaders. What we want to do is narrow down which is the king of the hill.

Tide is the first brand that comes to the mind of many people when they think of doing laundry.

And that’s easy to understand since more than 40 million American households use the detergent. Tide is, by far, the most sought-after laundry detergent in the United States.

Persil, produced by Germany-based consumer goods company Henkel, has been the top-selling detergent in most parts of Europe for many years. However, it is relatively new in the United States, first hitting the shelves in 2015.

While Tide is the best-seller in the US market space, Persil is becoming more and more popular and was even rated better than Tide in many independent studies in which specialists determined the cleaning power of the popular detergent brands in the American market.

If you are looking to try one of these detergents for the first time or trying to make a switch, then you may be wondering:

What is the difference between Persil and Tide?

In this short post, we will be answering this question and explaining how the two detergents measure up in terms of:

  • Cleaning ability
  • Scent
  • Price
  • Product offerings
  • And lots more

Persil Vs. Tide Which Detergent Cleans Better?

If you are looking for a quick comparison of Persil vs. Tide, here are the key things you need to know:

History: Owned by P&G, Tide was founded back in the year 1946. And thanks to its great branding and commitment to innovation, the brand has become America’s best-selling detergent. On the other hand, Persil is owned by Henkle and has been around since 1907, although they only entered the US market five years ago.

Cleaning Power: Both detergents rank high in most independent studies due to their excellent cleaning power. Below is a table showing how the two brands faired in tests conducted recently:

Tester Persil Results Tide Results Best Overall Best Value
Good Housekeeping Best Detergent Best Detergent Packs
Consumer Reports Best for Sensitive Skins and Tough Stains Best for Grass Stains
The Wirecutter Not Ranked Best Detergent

Scents: While Persil offers only two fragrances (Original, and Intense Fresh), Tide detergent is available in six different fragrances. Most customers like the smell of both brands,  even though some find the Persil’s scent overpowering. Both Tide and Persil offer fragrance-free detergents for people with sensitive skin.


Checking Out Pricing

Price Point: Persil and Tide are both premium laundry detergents, so they are pricier than other brands. However, there is no big difference in the prices of the two. If you a smart shopper, you can get both of them at excellent prices.


We wanted to check the prices on a couple of products as close to each other in quantities as well as quality.

Tide Pods 3 in 1, Laundry Detergent Pacs, Spring Meadow Scent, 81 Count

As these prices are pulled direct from the suppliers’ site, these are easy enough to compare. We wanted to ensure Persil Vs Tide pricing was accurate.

We put these up against the Persil ProClean Discs Laundry Detergent, Original, 40 Count, Pack of 2 = 80 total count.


Product Offerings: While the Persil offers a total of 7 detergents, Tide offers more than 40. Also, Tide has detergents that are specially formulated to meet every cleaning need: hypoallergenic, heavy-duty stains, odor defense, high-efficiency washers, cold water washers, etc. Persil, on the other hand, keeps its product offerings simple. They design their detergent to be effective in all types of washers – whether regular and high efficiency.

Tide Vs. Persil

Distribution: Both detergents have a wide distribution. They can be found in supermarkets, retail stores, and online at places such as Amazon.


Final Thoughts On Persil Vs Tide Detergents


Persil ProClean did an exceptional job cleaning the clothing. It has a very powerful scent, which some may find too strong, possibly. The Tide Original is a staple purchase for most homes across the country. Being the brand leader for decades it can be said that this is the scent associated with freshly washed clothes.

It's only fair to share...Share on Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Pin on Pinterest
Share on LinkedIn

Leave a Comment:

Persil Vs Tide The Detergent Battle Rages On

time to read: 4 min